Not all encyclopedias are created equal

August 3rd, 2013 by

Wikipedia has some way to go before it can comprehensively replace the great Britannica in all its many roles. From Shackleton’s South, a passage in which he and his crew are stranded on a drifting ice-floe in the Weddell Sea, November 1915:

In addition to the daily hunt for food, our time was passed in reading the few books that we had managed to save from the ship. The greatest treasure in the library was a portion of the “Encyclopaedia Britannica.” This was being continually used to settle the inevitable arguments that would arise. The sailors were discovered one day engaged in a very heated discussion on the subject of Money and Exchange. They finally came to the conclusion that the Encyclopaedia, since it did not coincide with their views, must be wrong.

“For descriptions of every American town that ever has been, is, or ever will be, and for full and complete biographies of every American statesman since the time of George Washington and long before, the Encyclopaedia would be hard to beat. Owing to our shortage of matches we have been driven to use it for purposes other than the purely literary ones though; and one genius having discovered that the paper, used for its pages had been impregnated with saltpetre, we can now thoroughly recommend it as a very efficient pipe-lighter.”

We also possessed a few books on Antarctic exploration, a copy of Browning and one of “The Ancient Mariner.” On reading the latter, we sympathized with him and wondered what he had done with the albatross; it would have made a very welcome addition to our larder.

Tags: , , ,

3 Responses to “Not all encyclopedias are created equal”

  1. Shay Simmons Says:

    I remember attending a talk given by Terry Waite in which he related some of his experiences while held captive in Lebanon.

    He said that he finally convinced his captors to allow him a copy of Bible and was quite distressed when they brought him a copy of a modern translation when he longed for the familiar eloquence of the KJV.

  2. trade show Says:

    go here for the greatest china manufacturers anywhere

  3. Best Audio Rack Says:

    Regular exercising on this machine can burn up a large amount of calories and
    that too in a very short time. The real problem is that the whole reason we
    have things like mp3 players and headphones is because we want to take our music wherever we want, and outdoors is where all the noise is.
    What we are actually doing is projecting anger from our own energy source onto Karen reinforcing her emotional
    state.

Leave a Reply